San Francisco city leaders said Tuesday they would continue law enforcement strategies that they say have significantly reduced retail theft over the past year.
At a press conference, Mayor Daniel Lurie and others credited the drop in numbers to strategies that included a summertime blitz operation that saw a Police Department task force partner with retailers to conduct in-store operations and push to address the reselling of merchandise on the street, as well as the continued aggressive prosecutions of retail theft.
The blitz operation, as the Police Department termed it, involved a San Francisco Police Department Retail Loss Prevention Team conducting undercover operations inside retail stores and local businesses.
A crackdown on reselling stolen goods, known as fencing, targeted areas around the BART plazas at 16th and 24th streets in the Mission.
The representative for those areas on the county Board of Supervisors, District 9 representative Jackie Fielder, has questioned the effectiveness of the crackdowns and called for hearings that could lead to more clearly defined benchmarks for success. Fielder did not attend Tuesday’s press conference.
The results and what officials plan to do next
Police have made 844 arrests for retail theft in the last six months, Lurie said at the press conference at SFPD headquarters in the Mission Bay neighborhood that was also attended by Police Chief Derrick Lew, District Attorney Brooke Jenkins, and District 2 Supervisor Stephen Sherrill.
Lurie said that number represented a 27% increase from the previous six-month period.
Lurie and Lew said the increased enforcement strategies would continue into the fall.
“Retail theft puts workers at risk, raise (sic) prices for customers, and can drive businesses out of our neighborhoods,” Lurie said. “That is why we are taking urgent action to stop it.”
While arrests were up, reports of theft decreased over the last six months by 20%, he said.
SFPD also made 100 arrests for fencing in July and August.
Lew said the SFPD’s Retail Loss Prevention Team was partnering with large and small business owners to embed officers inside stores for targeted operations.
“Stealing from local businesses does tremendous damage to our city,” Lew said. “It endangers employees. It hurts our local retailers. And, ultimately, it harms our local economy when neighborhoods lose vital businesses.”
He said the Police Department would focus on training, increasing retail theft enforcement operations, and expanding partnerships with more businesses to continue the progress seen in the numbers.
Roughly $410,000 in stolen merchandise was recovered by the SFPD in the past year, according to Lew and the Mayor’s Office.
Jenkins said her office was pushing to change the state constitution to allow repeat retail theft offenders accused of new thefts to be held without bail or on high bail amounts while awaiting trial. She said one of the current problems with prosecuting defendants for retail theft is that they often fail to show up for court dates.
Public defender challenges crackdown approach
The San Francisco Public Defender’s Office, meanwhile, said in late August, when a slate of retail theft arrests were announced, that the DA’s Office should focus less on strategies that favor incarceration in favor of those that involve alternative programs for what a spokesperson called low-level offenders.
“Pouring public resources into retail-theft crackdowns may protect multibillion-dollar corporations, but it does nothing to address the economic desperation that drives property crime,” the Public Defender’s Office said. “Investments in community health and job opportunities address poverty and deter these offenses, not incarceration.”
Lurie, Lew, and Sherrill all said the city has more work to do despite the improved numbers and said that continuing the current focus on reducing retail theft was the best way to accomplish that.
Jenkins and Sherrill both attributed retail theft as the reason multiple grocery stores have closed in recent years in the city. Sherrill said employees often complained about safety concerns that the Police Department’s strategies were trying to address.
“It’s about doubling down on what is going to make life in San Francisco better,” Sherrill said. “And ensuring that grocery stores and the people who work there are not threatened with theft every day is a big part of that.”
