A proposal to add 87 acres of unincorporated land into the city of American Canyon was further delayed Friday amid a leadership shakeup at Napa County’s Local Agency Formation Commission, which regulates municipal growth.
Napa LAFCO Executive Director Brendon Freeman, who joined the agency 18 years ago, was placed on paid administrative leave following a performance evaluation by agency commissioners at an Aug. 27 closed session meeting, just two weeks before a hearing on the hotly contested acreage just north of the city.
“Something’s fishy,” said Sam Clerici Sr., a second-generation resident of Watson Lane, part of the area planned for annexation.
Friday’s hearing, called a protest hearing, is required when an area poised to become part of a city has landowners and registered voters living on it — like the 87-acre Paoli Loop/Watson Lane area proposed for annexation into the city of American Canyon, largely so the city can build a road to divert traffic from State Route 29.
Since LAFCO commissioners approved the proposal in June, Watson Lane residents have attended American Canyon City Council meetings and met one-on-one with city officials to express concerns over the incorporation into the city.
The process felt rushed, residents have said, and annexation would radically change their lives. For generations, Watson Lane residents have lived a rural lifestyle, many keeping livestock and enjoying the freedom of living on unincorporated land.
Neighbors skeptical
A pre-annexation agreement sent to residents by the city of American Canyon ensures some protections for existing land uses, but many residents on Friday said they don’t want to sign it.
Now, with Freeman on leave, some said their mistrust in the process has grown.
“I’m shocked that he’s not here,” said Clerici on Friday, referring to Freeman’s absence from the canceled hearing.
“He was really helpful and transparent,” said Clerici.
Several residents who showed up were relieved that they could have more time to review the proposal and the pre-annexation agreement.
On Friday, Clerici and a handful of neighbors showed up to contest the proposal at the Napa LAFCO office. After around 30 minutes, they went back home.
The protest hearing was moved to Nov. 10, said LAFCO Chair and Napa City Council member Beth Painter, speaking after Friday’s truncated meeting. Painter said she received two letters requesting the continuation, which prompted LAFCO to reschedule.
Several residents who showed up to present a written protest were relieved that they could have more time to review the proposal and the pre-annexation agreement.
Search for successor begins
According to a LAFCO commission meeting from June 1, the agency’s executive director is the only staffer required to be physically present at a protest hearing.
On Friday, Painter said that the commission’s “goal” is to appoint a new executive director by the Nov. 10 hearing. She could not provide further comment on the staffing change, citing personnel confidentiality.
Painter said that the decision to place Freeman on leave was unrelated to the protest hearing. But residents said they’re skeptical.
“I think they’re going to appoint somebody that is going to favor them,” said Clerici.
American Canyon Mayor Pierre Washington weighed in ahead of the canceled protest hearing, stating that he respects Watson Lane residents’ concerns.
“My focus remains on the residents affected by the Paoli Loop and Watson Lane annexation and ensuring that the process is fair, transparent and consistent with the law,” said Washington over the phone.
“Whatever the outcome, I believe it is important that we continue listening to one another,” he said.
