Supporters and opponents of an affordable housing complex for senior farmworkers in Half Moon Bay began gearing up for a battle at the ballot box following a unanimous City Council vote Tuesday that put the matter up for a popular vote.
An ordinance authorizing the project and the lease of city-owned property at 555 and 535 Kelly Ave. to a nonprofit affordable housing developer, Mercy Housing, was approved in May by a divided City Council vote of 3-2 after years of planning.
But a group of residents who opposed the project and its planning process used a provision of the state constitution that triggers a referendum on an ordinance passed by a City Council if they can gather enough signatures to qualify it for the ballot.
Opponents asked residents who wanted to have an opportunity to cancel the City Council’s approval of the project to sign the referendum so they could challenge it at the ballot box or force the City Council to withdraw it. That drew outrage from supporters who felt that the City Council’s approval should be the final say.
Supporters of the housing project criticized the signature-gathering campaign and sought to move the project forward after the City Council voted for it. But once opponents qualified the referendum for the ballot last month, those who wanted the ordinance to survive were forced to support the idea of the election because the City Council’s only other option would have been to rescind the ordinance and cancel the project.
Campaign shifts to November
Voters will decide in the November general election whether to pass the same ordinance the City Council approved authorizing the construction of a five-story complex with 40 permanent, supportive, affordable apartment units reserved for up to 86 older and retired farmworkers or agricultural workers.
Michael Ferreira, who is the referendum’s main financial backer and is a former Half Moon Bay mayor and planning commissioner, said in an email that he would transition the campaign to qualify the ordinance for the ballot into one that opposed its passage. He said he would likely put more money into the oppositional campaign, after donating about $2,000 to the signature-gathering campaign.
Ferreira raised several objections to the project and the process in an appeal to the Planning Commission in 2024 and voiced them at multiple City Council meetings, including the five-story height of the building, which would be above the three-story limit imposed by zoning downtown, and the way the project had escalated from four stories to the fifth with little public input.
He also raised objections to the way the project secured its approvals for fewer parking spaces and more units through reliance on what he called an incorrect interpretation of a law making such allowances, the state’s density bonus law.
Supporters of the project, including local residents and representatives from Mercy Housing and the local nonprofit that will provide services at the complex, Ayudando Latinos A Sonar, known as ALAS, told councilmembers during the public comment period Tuesday night that they preferred the project would have moved ahead after the councilmembers approved the ordinance themselves.
But they said they were confident voters would support the project and asked for the ordinance to be put on the ballot to keep the project alive. The council’s only other choice would have been to withdraw the ordinance, essentially canceling the project, which has been in the planning stages since 2022.
The ordinance authorized the lease of the city-owned property for 99 years at a rate of $1 per year. The dollar amount is a common arrangement for what is essentially a donation of the land to a nonprofit organization to operate or build affordable housing.
But Mayor Debbie Ruddock said the length of the lease and the vague language around who would actually be eligible to be housed there were two of her concerns when she voted against the ordinance in May, along with District 3 City Councilmember Paul Nagengast.
The original project identified “retired farmworkers” but later said anyone older than 54 years old who derives substantial income from agriculture would qualify, according to Ruddock.
Both Ruddock and Nagengast said ahead of their votes in opposition of the ordinance authorizing the lease in May that they felt there were problems with how the project received approval from the city’s Planning Commission, which they said relied on an expansive interpretation of the state’s density bonus law. That law allows housing developments to exceed some local zoning regulations around height and parking requirements if the projects meet certain criteria.
One of those criteria is whether the proposed development is within a half-mile of a major transit stop, as defined by having two bus or train lines intersecting and arriving at least every 15 minutes during peak travel times. Half Moon Bay has no such stop within the distance required from the development.
City staff relied on a combination of less frequent bus stops and the on-demand SamTrans Ride Plus service offered by the San Mateo County Transit District as a way to gain the backing of the state’s Housing and Community Development for the project.
The city later passed a resolution against relying on such a justification in the future in 2024, after the project had been approved on those grounds.
Supporters defend project
But that and other unique characteristics about the project, including its 100% affordable units and alliance of applicants that could offer development and services, were reasons District 1 City Councilmember Robert Brownstone said opponents of the project who were worried about more, tall buildings popping up downtown had nothing to fear.
“You don’t get nonprofit, affordable housing builders such as Mercy, MidPen, you don’t see those folks flowing in, all of a sudden building these skyscrapers often. It’s a long process,” Brownstone said during the May 5 approval vote. “After folks see what it takes to, like here, create a project like this, it’s not like you’re going to have all these builders running in here to try to build these tall projects.”
The proposed building’s tallest point would be about 54.5 feet high, about 12.5 feet taller than the nearby Boys and Girls Club and about 14.5 feet higher than a nearby church.

Representatives of Mercy Housing and ALAS told councilmembers during public comments Tuesday that they supported putting the ordinance before voters rather than rescinding it altogether.
“We are the voters,” said Belinda Hernandez-Arriaga, CEO of ALAS. “So let’s decide to support the dreams of our senior farmworkers. We want to see 555 Kelly happen because so many are counting on this,” she said.
Kelly Hollywood, associate director at Mercy Housing, also urged councilmembers to keep the project alive the only way it still could, by putting the ordinance on the ballot in November and allowing supporters to campaign to get it finally passed by voters.
Carolina Carbajal, a local farmworker, urged councilmembers to help get the project they had already approved over the finish line.
“There is no dignified retirement for farmworkers,” Carbajal told councilmembers in Spanish during the public comment period through a translator. “We work excessively until our bodies can’t take anymore. And when they’re elderly, they can’t even move. So many suffer from different diseases like hypertension. As a matter of fact, some have even amputated part of their body,” she said, also asking what the threat was to the community.
Carbajal said it was time to support local residents who had worked so hard for the community.
The project would not cost any money from the city’s general fund.
