The Alameda County Board of Supervisors approved a new policy Tuesday that requires the board to remain neutral on most matters associated with international relations and foreign affairs.
On a split 3-2 vote, the board decided to remain neutral in the face of international conflicts, foreign policy matters and geopolitical disputes.
The new policy gives supervisors the option to consider such matters if they “directly concern” county governance or operations.
Supervisors Nate Miley and Lena Tam introduced the proposal and were joined by Supervisor David Haubert in voting to approve it.
“Institutional neutrality does not mean indifference, silence or a lack of compassion,” Tam said prior to the vote. “It simply offers a constructive approach to addressing concerns while keeping the board focused on its responsibility to serve our residents.”
She mentioned that the county advocates for and provides services to immigrant and refugee communities, regardless of their nationality, religion or politics, and that the board has adopted an ethical investment policy, which has yet to be implemented but is intended to help the county avoid investments in companies it feels are harmful, including those with objectionable ties to foreign governments.
Institutional neutrality does not mean indifference, silence or a lack of compassion. It simply offers a constructive approach to addressing concerns while keeping the board focused on its responsibility to serve our residents.
Supervisor Lena Tam
“We can still recognize global suffering and disagree with the actions that take place around the world without making the county an institutional participant in geopolitical disputes,” she said.
Tam and Miley both said that the policy doesn’t prevent individual supervisors from taking positions on such topics.
“There’s so much going on globally and internationally, where do you draw the line,” Miley said. “I mean, we can weigh in on almost anything and everything. That’s why we have a Congress. Part of their job is to take on international affairs. It’s not our role as an official body.”
What it means to be a ‘welcoming county‘
Supervisors Elisa Marquez and Nikki Fortunato Bas voted against the policy proposal.
Fortunato Bas mentioned the board’s “welcoming county” policy, which designates Alameda County as being formally welcoming to immigrants and refugees.
“The welcoming county resolution was one of those resolutions that took into account the fact that we’re a global community where one-third of our residents are immigrants and refugees born in another country and to me, welcoming means that we are seeing and hearing our residents and that our residents feel seen, heard, and valued,” Fortunato Bas said.
“And I do believe our local economy is tied to global policies, that our county budget is tied to federal and international policies that impact funding for our safety net,” she said.
She also said she received 341 emails expressing opposition to the new policy and that about 20 speakers at Tuesday’s meeting also opposed it.

