Below the poster proclaiming this year’s Banned Books Week slogan, Renee Rettig propped up “Gender Queer,” “Maus” and several other books in her Hayward bookstore Books on B.
“My whole intention was to create a community for our area to come to,” Rettig said. “Free speech comes with being an independent bookseller, and [the store has] always celebrated the freedom to be.”
Books on B joined bookstores across the nation for Banned Books Week from Oct. 4 to Oct. 10, an annual promotion of free speech. Stores showcased books on the American Library Association’s list of the most challenged books from 2025.
This list reflects just a portion of books subjected to intensified censorship in recent years. A California law prohibits banning books in public libraries and schools, but across the country book challenges, a formal request to restrict access to a book, have continued. In 2025 alone, parents and school board members challenged more than 4,200 books. Schools, cities and other authorities banned almost 7,000 books, according to PEN America
CEO Allison Hill of the American Booksellers Association spearheads the organization representing many independent bookstores to fight censorship, financial threats and other challenges.
“Independent bookstores are doing so much to champion Black, brown and LGBTQ+ authors, to talk about book bans, to really help communities understand what’s at stake when free expression is being challenged,” Hill said.
Besides displaying banned books, more than 400 independent bookstores nationwide, including Books on B and Banter Bookshop in Fremont, had special read-ins with Libro.fm, an audiobook app that partners with independent bookstores.
Freedom to read
As co-owners of BookSmart in Morgan Hill, Brad Jones and Cinda Meister find censorship intolerable. For over the 30 years the store has run, Jones and Meister have intentionally made customers’ purchases untraceable.
“There can be a lot of ways that people can use [a customer’s purchase] in ways that bend the truth,” Jones said. “Most online companies track purchases because they think it’s a sales tool, but we don’t like to track what people are reading. It’s not anybody’s business.”
Artist Nico Ong has shopped at independent bookstores like BookSmart ever since they were young. Ong appreciates the resources the stores offer the community, including banned books.
“It’s really interesting to see bookstores give people tools for creating their own ways of standing up for free speech,” they said. “It’s really heartwarming to see bookstores spotlight reasons why books were banned.”
Bill Petrocelli served on the ABA’s board of directors. As co-owner of the Marin County store Book Passage in Corte Madera, he’s witnessed firsthand the positive community impact of offering author forums.
“Our customers ask a lot of questions when we have an author event,” Petrocelli said. “When we first started I thought to myself, ‘This is the best part of the business, when the author and the readers can sit down and just talk.’”
Reading bridges understanding
In downtown Campbell, Recycle Bookstore customer John Kraft finds a deeper level of contemplation via the shelves of this and other indie stores. As Kraft browsed the aisles, hopping from sci-fi to Greek mythology, he admired the wide variety.
“Having a selection of books where somebody can educate themselves and voice an opinion is a good thing,” Kraft said. “I think prompting people to think about their surroundings is certainly better versus going about life passively.”
As someone who just moved from Texas and is still exploring the Bay Area, BookSmart customer Sathya Mabbu has curated a diverse home library by shopping at independent bookstores.
“Independent bookstores are less afraid to sell banned books more than chains,” Mabbu said. “Chains might not want to anger the government or have repercussions. But independent bookstores, I feel like they can and they do carry banned books.”
“Suppressing solves nothing. If we are going to live up to the values our country has been built upon, it is essential to know ourselves and understand each other. We’re only going to have that through reading.”
— Renee Rettig, owner of Books on B
Rettig at Books on B presents different viewpoints to her community through open mics and customers’ recommendations. She is no stranger to combatting hate. In partnership with San Francisco’s Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, Books on B hosts drag storytimes that have faced backlash.
“It’s heartbreaking that we have a protocol to anticipate blowback when we want to celebrate diversity,” Rettig said. “Suppressing solves nothing. If we are going to live up to the values our country has been built upon, it is essential to know ourselves and understand each other. We’re only going to have that through reading.”
Maggie Hu is a member of the class of 2029 at the Harker School in San Jose.
Editor’s note: This story is part of the annual Mosaic Journalism Program for Bay Area high school students, an intensive course in journalism. Students in the program report and photograph stories under the guidance of professional journalists.
