The Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors delayed considering a pay bump for board members at its meeting Tuesday, rescheduling the discussion for January.
Supervisor Justin Cummings has been leading an effort to give the board more leeway in setting its salaries, which are currently linked to the pay rate of Superior Court judges.
But Cummings acknowledged that the timing was not optimal, given that the Board of Supervisors passed a resolution in early August declaring the county to be in a state of fiscal distress. The county is facing a budget deficit of nearly $50 million, which could grow to about $67 million annually if voters reject a half-cent sales tax increase in November.
Santa Cruz County supervisors currently make 62% of Superior Court judges’ salaries under an arrangement that was part of the county code until 1997, when the Board of Supervisors broke the link.
The decision was made to avoid potential raises that could be triggered at a time when the county was facing another budget crunch, according to a county staff report from Human Resources Director Ajita Patel.
The Board of Supervisors reestablished the link between the two pay rates in 2021 to provide an external benchmark and depoliticize discussions around salaries.
But Cummings pointed out that pay for Santa Cruz County supervisors has not kept pace with surrounding counties.
Santa Cruz County supervisors make about 12% less than those in surrounding counties, earning about $12,644 per month, according to the staff report.
‘Not a money-making situation’
Supervisors Manu Koenig and Kimberly De Serpa, however, said the issue went beyond bad timing, arguing at Tuesday’s meeting that the change was unnecessary.
“We ran for office because we wanted to serve the public,” De Serpa said. “This is not a money-making situation and our salary is adequate.”
Cummings said he thought it was better to consider the matter in January because a new District 4 representative will be on the board after Tony Nunez won the seat in the primary election. Cummings said he was more interested in changing the process than the actual salary amount.
Supervisors will also know by then whether Superior Court judges received a pay increase this year. They were not given one by the Judicial Council, the administrative arm of the state’s court system, but could receive a midyear increase in October.
De Serpa said she was willing to table the conversation but did not know how she would vote in January.
The vote was 4-1 to continue the matter, with Koenig voting “no.”
