It might seem easy to give yourself a raise, but the issue has divided the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors, which will consider Tuesday a proposal to increase Board members’ salaries.
Board members voted to advance a plan to remove language in the county code that caps their salaries at a rate the county does not control. They will consider finalizing that proposal and salary increases.
The vote came just days after the county passed a resolution declaring a state of fiscal distress as it faces a nearly $50 million annual budget deficit that could balloon to $67 million in coming budget years.
The five elected members of the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors make less than board members in nearby counties, according to a county staff report.
Staff has put forward two plans for consideration, including one with two annual 4% cost-of-living adjustments followed by a 3.5% adjustment in the third year, and another that would add an additional 4% increase over the first two years.
Board members could alternatively set their own salaries. They could also vote to unlink the two pay rates without increasing their salaries.
Their salary before benefits is $12,644 per month and costs the county $16,545 after health care and other benefits. Both figures are roughly 12% below those of board members in other Bay Area and Central Coast counties.
Their pay has been capped at 62% of Superior Court judges’ salaries since 2021, which District 3 Supervisor Justin Cummings called arbitrary when the Board voted 3-2 on Aug. 11 to move forward with unlinking the two.
He told colleagues during the meeting that the county considers several defined factors when setting salaries for its workforce that are not part of the process for setting judges’ salaries statewide, and that tying the two together did not make sense.
“I had been interested in us considering reforming this process anyway, and then this year it turned out that judges were going to not get a salary increase at all, which meant the Board of Supervisors was not going to get a salary increase at all, and I just didn’t think that that was fair,” Cummings told Board members.
The county uses criteria including the Consumer Price Index, comparable market data, pay trends for other county labor groups and internal alignment of pay structures. The Judicial Council — the administrative arm of the Superior Court that sets salaries for judges — does not take those factors into account or base salaries on Santa Cruz County’s market.
‘Super bad timing’
But Supervisors Manu Koenig and Kimberly De Serpa said it was a bad time to consider the matter, citing the county’s precarious financial situation.
The county placed a measure on the November ballot to increase the sales tax in unincorporated parts of the county by a half-cent to try to bridge the looming budget gap.
“It’s just super bad timing,” Koenig told colleagues. “We literally at our last meeting just declared that we’re in a state of fiscal distress, just put a measure on the ballot that asks everyone to sacrifice a little bit, and, so if we don’t do that, if we don’t sacrifice, why should the public trust us?”
He and De Serpa voted against moving the plan forward, while Cummings and Supervisors Felipe Hernandez and Monica Martinez voted to direct county staff to return with numbers to consider, along with finalized language for a vote on an ordinance to codify the change.
Future salary increases would require future votes.

