Families of people killed by Vallejo Police Department officers confronted city officials last week at a public forum on police accountability, the first since the revelation of officer misconduct, coupled with several high-profile police killings, first rocked Vallejo in 2020.
Facing the panelists, Angela Sullivan, whose nephew Ronell Foster was killed by VPD Officer Ryan McMahon in 2018, cried into her hands between intervals of standing up to call out her nephew’s killing.
Foster was unarmed and had been pulled over for riding his bike without a light.
At the Aug. 12 meeting, families demanded the firing and decertification of officers and changes to VPD employees’ contract with the city, which currently allows officers to be rehired after facing firing.
An estimated 20 people have been killed by Vallejo Police Department officers since 2010 — in some cases, by the same officer. Several are still out on patrol in Vallejo, according to current employee records — some, thanks to the contractual binding arbitration clause, including Officer Jarrett Tonn, who shot and killed 22-year-old Sean Monterrosa in 2020.

Last week’s three-hour meeting, organized by the NAACP’s Vallejo chapter, was the city’s first chance to reckon with the fallout from years of police violence.
The eight-member panel included City Manager Harry Black, City Council members Tonia Lediju and Alexander Matias, City Attorney Veronica Nebb, VPD Chief Jason Ta, Black Women Organized for Political Action President LaTressa Wilson Alford, Police Oversight and Accountability Commission member John Lewis and civil rights attorney Melissa Nold.
The night’s moderator was Landis Graden, a Vallejo resident and business strategist who synthesized pre-submitted audience questions for the panel.
Many panelists and attendees agreed: The town hall was necessary, though about a decade late.
“This was long overdue,” said Matias after the meeting. “We need to have these conversations.”
“Hopefully, this is the start of not just having touchpoint with our community with impacted families, but actually following through with action,” he said.
Families demand firings
For some, the town hall was just more talk.
“You’re sitting up here like this is OK, after our loved ones have been murdered,” said Kris Kelly, who stormed out of the room halfway through the meeting while Nebb spoke.
“At the end of the day, when we leave here, we leave here without our loved one,” Kelly said, walking out alongside her family members.
Kelly’s brother Mario Romero was shot and killed by former Vallejo police officers Sean Kenney and Dustin Joseph in 2012. AnhLoc Harris, Kelly’s sister, said she witnessed Romero’s killing and “has to live with it every day.”
Nobody has stepped up and said: ‘We screwed up. We’re deeply sorry. And this is what we’re going to do to fix it.’
John Lewis, member of Vallejo’s Police Oversight and Accountability Commission
Harris said firing and decertifying officers involved in killings would be the first step to a concrete measure of accountability, which so far has just been talk, she said.
The City Attorney’s Office is currently under review for allegedly destroying evidence related to police shootings after an ACLU request to the Vallejo City Council last July.
After the town hall, Nebb said the intentional destruction of evidence “did not occur” and that an independent investigation “found that there was no intentional wrongdoing by the person in the Police Department who got rid of that evidence.”
Badge-bending
The meeting was the first in what the NAACP’s Vallejo chapter says will be a series of town halls on the subject.
Patricia Hunter, president of the local chapter, said she saw the need for a town hall after families came out in droves to Vallejo City Council meetings in recent months to demand accountability following the long-awaited release of an investigation into VPD’s practice of badge-bending, in which officers bent back the tips of their metal badges each time they shot someone on the job.
“There’s still a lot to be said, a lot to be heard,” said Hunter. “We need to move forward.”
The “ritual,” as some called it, first came to light in 2020, the same year as the fatal shooting of Monterrosa and shortly after the fatal shooting of Willie McCoy in 2019.

An independent investigation into the practice by a former Sonoma County sheriff in 2021 concluded that while some of the 14 officers named in the report had violated department policies, the practice of badge-bending was not intended to honor police killings.
The report was finally released in June after being held up by lawsuits from the city to keep it under wraps.
“The reason we’re talking about badge-bending is because nobody has stepped up and said: ‘We screwed up. We’re deeply sorry. And this is what we’re going to do to fix it,’” said Lewis from Vallejo’s Police Oversight and Accountability Commission.
The seven-member commission was formed in 2022, but only just started meeting regularly this year.
In the past year, Hunter has met four times with representatives from the California Department of Justice to discuss ongoing police accountability measures for the city. In 2024, the DOJ recommended 45 reforms to VPD and the city — part of a settlement after the department filed a lawsuit in 2020 alleging a pattern of unconstitutional conduct by local police.
A city in the midst of reform
“When I first started, we were not transparent,” said Sgt. Rashad Hollis, a spokesman for VPD, after the town hall.
Hollis was hired in 2013. In recent years, he said he’s seen progress — largely due to the mandated reform efforts. Since 2021, the city has formed several bodies to enforce reform.
In the Police Department, those include the Chief’s Advisory Board and a Critical Incident Review Board. On the city’s side, that includes a Public Safety Council Subcommittee and the Police Oversight and Accountability Commission.
Lediju said that Black, who was appointed to the city manager position in July, would help lead the city toward further accountability measures.
“I’m expecting him to take this city further than we’ve ever been able to go,” she said.
When asked about the police contracts’ arbitration clause, Black, whose office leads contract discussions, said that “everything is always open to negotiation.”
Ultimately, the current contract takes power away from the city, he said.
“I know we have hopes of accountability,” said Graden while moderating. “But I just don’t foresee that unless we have some real change to the city charter. I don’t see that unless we have some real accountability at a disciplinary level.”
