An investigation released by the city of Vallejo on Thursday affirmed that Mayor Andrea Sorce sought a former employee’s removal and worked to turn people against her.
The investigation was launched following claims of a hostile work environment from a former high-level staffer, whose name was redacted throughout the 153-page report by investigators Douglas Ropel and Karen Herz, who were contracted by the city in June 2025.
The report said that the complainant worked for the city for six years prior to the investigation. Emails included as evidence showed that in recent years, the complainant presented regularly at City Council meetings and worked closely with former City Manager Andrew Murray, who stepped down from the role in May.
“Her false narrative about me and my work is disturbing and disruptive,” read an email from the ex-staffer, referring to Sorce, included in the investigation as evidence. “Her behavior is increasingly aggressive and causing undue stress.”
The email was sent in June 2025 after a City Council meeting in which Sorce publicly questioned whether the staffer had violated transparency laws.
The investigation was first brought to light at a heated meeting on Nov. 10, when the City Council ultimately rejected a bid to condemn the mayor for the actions outlined in the report. After an outpouring of support for the mayor from dozens of Vallejo residents, the council voted to release a redacted version of the investigation.
Calling out ‘corrupt practices’
In remarks ahead of the vote, the mayor told the council, “It’s all because I have the audacity to call out what appears to me to be corrupt practices — particularly in the Vallejo Police Department and the Vallejo City Attorney’s Office.”
Nevertheless, investigators said that Sorce’s actions amounted to multiple violations of Vallejo’s City Charter, Code of Ethics and Conduct and Municipal Code.
“Virtually all of the allegations raised against Mayor Sorce were substantiated,” the report stated.
The same investigation opposed claims that the ex-employee faced gender and age discrimination from her boss, a man whose name was redacted.
Investigators were also unable to prove that Sorce had a personal agenda against the complainant, who said the mayor partially blamed her for the firing of Sorce’s husband, Slater Matzke, from his role at the City Manager’s Office in 2020.
“Her false narrative about me and my work is disturbing and disruptive. Her behavior is increasingly aggressive and causing undue stress.”
Email from former Vallejo staff member, referring to Mayor Andrea Sorce
Matzke was a plaintiff in a wrongful termination lawsuit filed in 2021 that claimed his and others’ firing came as retaliation for calling out bad actors around a massive development deal on Mare Island.
Four City Council members were included as witnesses in the investigation: Peter Bregenzer, Helen-Marie Gordon, Charles Palmares and JR Matulac. All testified to Sorce’s public criticism of the complainant. Several affirmed that Sorce publicly said she wanted the complainant removed from her role.
“Bregenzer believes that the Mayor treats [redacted] with hostility, which emanates from the Mayor’s husband’s termination, citing comments by Mayor Sorce and her ‘groupies,’” stated the report of the council member’s testimony.
Formal complaint led to investigation
The roots of the investigation appeared to date back to an initial formal complaint filed to Human Resources by Sorce in March 2025, stating that the ex-staffer’s “action undermines my ability to lead the city effectively.”
Investigators said in the report that Sorce was repeatedly asked to be interviewed, but that she ultimately declined, making a motivation for driving out the complainant difficult to prove.
At the Nov. 10 meeting, Sorce and several City Council members challenged the claim that the mayor had been asked for an interview.
“This is the least transparent process I’ve seen in my two years as mayor,” Sorce said at the meeting.
The investigation is the latest in a string of harassment claims filed between former Vallejo staffers in the last decade, amounting to hefty legal costs for the cash-strapped city.

