Pickleball is causing a racket in Scotts Valley.
The Scotts Valley City Council on Wednesday night discussed continued complaints about noise and traffic from pickleball courts at Skypark, a park in a residential neighborhood in the city in the Santa Cruz Mountains.
Scotts Valley initially added temporary pickleball courts in 2014 within the park’s existing tennis courts at the top of a cul-de-sac. In 2018, the city restriped courts and added some permanent pickleball nets.
As the sport has grown more popular in the past dozen years, the city has received increased complaints from residents, leading to adjustments in court hours, including most recently in August, when an 8 p.m. closing time every night was established.
The city is now conducting a survey about the most recent changes with residents and Skypark pickleball court users through Nov. 30 and will present the findings at a December meeting of its Parks and Recreation Commission, which will consider whether to recommend any additional changes to Scotts Valley’s pickleball policies.
The City Council on Wednesday did not take any action but gave both local pickleball enthusiasts and impacted neighbors the chance to speak before discussing possible policy changes down the road, including limiting pickleball use to certain days of the week, building sound barriers between the courts and nearby homes, or partnering with local schools or private organizations that have their own courts.
Mark Dettle, president of the Santa Cruz Pickleball Club, told the council during public comment that pickleball is a rare recreational experience between people across generations, having first become popular among older adults before recently attracting a younger age range to the courts.
Carol Hagen, another speaker during public comment, said socialization is a big draw for pickleball.
“There’s the social component, and the physical component,” she said. “It’s a very welcoming environment, so yes, there will be crowds.”
But the crowds, and resulting traffic and noise from the courts, have led many residents around Skypark to complain to the city.
“I try not to be that get off my lawn type of person, but I’m there. It’s hard,” said Traci Waldheim, who told the council she is a resident of the cul-de-sac.
“People are trying, and I have to acknowledge that because there really are the pickleballers who want it to work,” she said. “That area was not designed for that many people.”
Councilmember Krista Jett said she would like the city to consider respite days with no pickleball allowed “so community members can have reliable, predictable respite days and know when they can expect quiet.”
Councilmember Derek Timm suggested that the city could partner with a local high school “to get pickleball in a location that’s not as impactful.”
‘Pickleball players, this is on you‘
Vice Mayor Steve Clark placed some of the blame on the people using the pickleball courts for not always following parking and traffic laws and said they could mitigate some of the impacts on the neighbors.
“Pickleball players, this is on you to solve in your community, and if you can’t, you will give us no choice but to solve it from our standpoint, and that’s not what we want to do,” Clark said.
Allison Pfefferkorn, the city’s recreation division manager, said pickleball is a subject that has frequently come up in discussions at conferences and with other cities, including Campbell in the South Bay.

In Martinez in Contra Costa County, the City Council shut down pickleball courts in March because of noise complaints from neighbors.
“This topic that we’re talking about tonight is not unique to our community,” Pfefferkorn said.

