East Palo Alto Mayor Webster Lincoln faced criticism at Tuesday’s City Council meeting over a proposed proclamation to remember October 7, 2023, when militant group Hamas launched an attack on Israel, igniting the Israel-Hamas War.
The “Day of Remembrance” proclamation was proposed for Wednesday, three years after the assault against Israel, which killed about 1,200 people and became the deadliest attack against Jewish people since the Holocaust.
“This proclamation is really out of respect for the victims who did not deserve to be murdered, taken hostage, or any of that,” Lincoln said at the meeting.
But some council members found the proclamation inappropriate and outside of the city’s scope of issues to address. Members of the public at the meeting criticized the proclamation since it did not recognize those killed in the aftermath of that day, when Israel counterattacked by bombing Palestine in a years-long war.
According to the Gaza Health Ministry, which manages health services in the Gaza Strip, over 74,000 people in Palestine have died since the Oct. 7, 2023, attack. A United Nations independent commission concluded in a report that Israeli authorities have committed and continue to commit genocide in their attacks on Palestine during the Israel-Hamas War.

“I find the proclamation deeply disturbing,” said Batool Zaro, a senior engineer for the city, during public comment. “There’s no recognition of the Palestinian civilians or hundreds of thousands of families who have experienced profound suffering and loss.”
Members in the audience brought signs either in protest or in support of the proclamation. One poster read “Free Palestine,” while others in the audience held up photos of civilians in Israel who died in the Oct. 7 attack.
“Dear Mayor Lincoln and City Council members, thank you for your leadership and courage,” said Anna Stepanenko, a member of the public at the meeting. “October 7 was a tragedy for Jewish people around the world.”
Council members debate proclamation
When the discussion returned to the council, Lincoln said that the proclamation was simply to honor the lives lost on that day.
“I don’t have a problem with honoring and recognizing the innocent people that were killed on this particular day,” he said. “I just don’t understand why we can’t recognize one group.”
Councilmember Carlos Romero also took issue with the proclamation not addressing or remembering the Palestinians who have died in the Israel-Hamas War.
“We have to recognize the grief on both sides,” Romero said. “To both sides, I feel your pain, but I think it is inappropriate for us to pass this and will be voting no on the issue.”
Romero and Councilmember Mark Dinan found the proclamation to be out of place, saying that the City Council should not be focusing on international issues.
“I don’t think anybody in Israel and Gaza cares at all about what the city of East Palo Alto is doing on these types of measures,” Dinan said. “I’m interested in moving the city of East Palo Alto forward and building housing, and things like this, as important as they are, they’re really a distraction from the mission of our city.”
Vice Mayor Ruben Abrica and Councilmember Martha Barragan were absent at the meeting. The city’s municipal code requires majority approval of the entire council for any action to pass, even when members are absent.
The proclamation needed at least three yes votes to go through. While Dinan ultimately supported the proclamation with Lincoln, Romero voted no, resulting in the proclamation failing to pass.

