Seven candidates running in the upcoming Berkeley City Council elections denounced the use of mass surveillance technology, including automated license plate reader cameras, at a press conference held Tuesday on the steps of City Hall.
The candidates were District 1 contenders Daria Wrubel and Moni Gangopadhyay, District 4 contender Majdi Gaith Abuhamdieh, District 7 contenders Aidan Hill and Syrak Micael, and District 8 contenders Michael Wallman and Mari Mendonca.
The press conference was organized by Berkeley Against Mass Surveillance, a network of organizations and individuals opposed to mass surveillance in the city.
All seven candidates have pledged not to vote for, approve or renew any mass surveillance system in Berkeley, and to remove the existing network of 52 ALPR cameras that the city uses for law enforcement, they said.
This technology is not to be trusted.
Daria Wrubel, District 1 candidate
Police departments use ALPR cameras to investigate crimes like stolen vehicles. However, privacy watchdogs have raised concerns about federal agencies being able to access the camera data — a potential violation of state law — and using it for targeted surveillance of immigrants and other vulnerable groups.
Over the last year, many Bay Area cities and counties have been reexamining their contracts with Flock Safety, the manufacturer of these cameras, considering the federal administration’s crackdown on immigrants and the company’s checkered record of sharing ALPR data with federal agencies like U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and U.S. Customs and Border Protection.
In May, following extensive public comment and debate, the Berkeley City Council voted 5-4 in favor of extending Berkeley’s contract with Flock Safety for its 52 ALPR cameras by up to 12 months.
At the same time, the City Council instructed staff to develop a new request for proposals, or RFP, to contract with vendors other than Flock Safety for surveillance technology.
Candidates seek delay on surveillance vote
At Tuesday’s press conference, the candidates urged the current City Council to delay its vote on choosing a new surveillance technology contractor, which, according to the RFP, could be as early as Nov. 17, they said.
If the vote does take place on Nov. 17, it will be after the Nov. 3 elections but before the new council members take office.
In a letter that the candidates sent to the council, they said, “If the lame-duck council takes up this crucial issue in its waning days, that will be widely perceived as an undemocratic move and flouting the expressed will of the electorate.”
At Tuesday’s press conference, the candidates said that technology like ALPR cameras threatens the city’s immigrant and trans communities, as well as individuals coming to California to seek reproductive care.
“This technology is not to be trusted,” said Wrubel. “If we gather the data, there is no way to keep it out of the hands of federal agents who are using it to kidnap our neighbors from our streets and lock them in concentration camps across the country.”
Hill acknowledged the utility of surveillance technology for the understaffed Police Department but said that he would not consider voting in favor of any surveillance technology unless the city retains complete control over the data and the data is end-to-end encrypted.

“If the city takes full responsibility for that data, and there’s community oversight through the Police Accountability Board, as well as the [Alameda County] Board of Supervisors, I can see that technology being in the city of Berkeley,” Hill said. “However, that’s not the case today.”
Others, like Gangopadhyay and Abuhamdieh, took a stronger stance, calling for a zero-tolerance policy toward mass surveillance altogether.
“I don’t want to be jarring in saying this, but you don’t want the West Bank to come to the West Coast,” said Abuhamdieh, who is a dual citizen Palestinian American, originally from the West Bank. “Berkeley is better than that, the East Bay is better than that, and the Bay Area is better than that.”
