Raised: 41300

Goal: 200000

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.

Help us raise for local news

raised Goal

Learn more Give now
  • DONATE TO SUPPORT LOCAL NEWS!
  • Sign In
  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS

  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
Skip to content
Local News Matters

Local News Matters

Connecting audiences with quality, local news

  • DONATE TO SUPPORT LOCAL NEWS!
  • Sign In
Sign In
  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
Posted inLocal News

California bills would set first-of-their-kind standards for wildfire smoke damage

by Levi Sumagaysay, CalMatters September 8, 2026September 8, 2026

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
Gil Barel in her son’s room in Pasadena on Aug. 2, 2026. Barel and her family are still waiting for their home, a duplex they had rented for eight years before the January 2025 Eaton Fire, to be cleaned up and free of toxic materials before they move back in. (Ariana Drehsler for CalMatters)

TWO SMOKE-DAMAGE BILLS awaiting the governor’s signature address a longstanding issue brought to the fore by the Los Angeles County fires: When is it safe for wildfire survivors to move back into their homes?

After the deadly January 2025 fires, which destroyed more than 16,000 structures, the state Insurance Department estimates that more than 13,000 out of 40,000 claims involved smoke damage. 

The fires burned for nearly a month. Debris and emissions contained a mixture of trees, brush and manufactured materials made up of  plastics, metals and more — raising concerns about toxic contents left in homes that are still standing but may be dangerous to live in.

Many survivors with homes that did not burn down have yet to return to them 21 months later. Their homes reeked of smoke and they found ash, soot and char inside. They await test results for things such as lead and asbestos. They wait for homes to be repaired, cleaned up and cleared of toxic materials after months of back-and-forth with their insurance companies. Along the way, fire survivors, experts and insurers have all pointed to the lack of standards around smoke damage.

Assembly Bill 1642 will set “a first-in-the-nation standard for testing and remediation,” said Assemblymember John Harabedian, a Pasadena Democrat, about the bill he authored. Remediation is the removal of contaminants or hazards, and fixing possible ill effects. 

The bill passed in conjunction with Assembly Bill 1795, authored by Assemblymember Mike Gipson, a Gardena Democrat. Gipson’s legislation will incorporate the new standards and require insurance companies to abide by them. The governor has until the end of the month to sign both bills; one cannot become law without the other.

“We were hearing from survivors that they weren’t getting a fair shake from their insurance companies,” Harabedian told CalMatters. “Kudos to survivor groups that worked with us on this. We hope others don’t have to go through what they went through.”

The bills are just two of several pieces of legislation to come out of the Eaton and Palisades fires meant to set clearer standards, hold insurers accountable and improve the recovery process after a wildfire.

Smoke damage figures prominently in lawsuits and legal actions against two big insurers in California: State Farm, which insures about 20% of the state’s property insurance market, and the last-resort FAIR Plan. The insurance department has accused both of delaying and denying smoke-damage claims. 

Los Angeles County sued State Farm last week, alleging unfair business practices in its handling of claims from the 2025 fires. The lawsuit cited the findings of the insurance department’s investigation, including that the company denied or discouraged requests for environmental testing and refused to reimburse policyholders for testing they paid for themselves. Also among the allegations was that for standing homes, the company sent preferred restoration companies that typically “offered an inadequate and unsafe cleaning method.”

State Farm “strongly disagrees” with the county lawsuit’s characterization of the company’s claims response, said spokesperson Sevag Sarkissian.

Standing but not move-in ready

Kareem Ali’s Altadena home is one of the few left standing on his cul-de-sac, but he and his wife haven’t been able to move back in. 

Instead, they have been living in a donated RV on their property since August. 

State Farm paid for them to live in other places from January 2025 until April of this year, when the insurer refused to reimburse them for rent at an $8,000-a-month one-bedroom that it had recommended to Ali. Ali quit paying rent then,  and the rent for May, June and July is unpaid. 

As for their smoke-damaged home, State Farm denied their request for environmental testing, so they paid $3,000 out of pocket for it. The insurer declined to reimburse them, and has since delayed and denied claims for cleanup. Some of the delays are because the insurer has assigned at least six or seven adjusters to their case, Ali said. 

“Every time we got some sort of momentum on our claim, they’d randomly switch,” he said.

So Ali said they spent the money that the company has given them so far for their personal belongings coverage. They hired contractors to clean, remove insulation and replace the carpet. When they told State Farm more repairs are needed but they ran out of money, the insurer denied their claim, he said.

Meanwhile, they’ve continued to pay State Farm their monthly premiums. Ali said he asked their adjuster: “What are we paying for if we’re not going to get coverage?”

Elisa Jacobs Nixon is in the same boat. She and her family haven’t been able to move back into their Altadena home, either, primarily because of months of back-and-forth with State Farm about smoke-damage testing and cleanup. 

The insurer initially ignored results of the May 2025 environmental testing she paid $6,000 for herself. So her public adjuster — a private insurance professional who handles claims on behalf of policyholders — advised her to get a contractor’s bid for the work that needed to be done because of the findings. That worked. Within days, State Farm sent its own industrial hygienist, Nixon said. 

Both the initial report and the one State Farm ordered had similar findings, including about high levels of contaminants. The most recent test also found asbestos.   

Now, even though Nixon and her family remain displaced, things finally seem to be moving forward, she said.

“This has completely hijacked my life, my kids’ lives, it’s just taken over everything,” Nixon said. “That’s why these parameters (in the bills) are so important. My hope is this will spread across the U.S. and help disaster survivors everywhere.”

What smoke-damage bills will do

Under Harabedian’s bill, the Department of Toxic Substances Control would have to create standards for lead and asbestos testing, repair and removal by the end of 2028. By the end of 2029, it would have to establish similar standards for other contaminants, including heavy metals, cyanide and lithium. 

Gipson’s bill creates a legal presumption that if ash, soot, char or other combustion byproducts are in a standing home after a wildfire, then smoke damage in the property is the result of wildfire for insurance purposes. Also included in the bill: Insurers must inspect properties within 30 days of claims; would be responsible for the cost of testing needed to restore properties to their pre-loss conditions; and cannot stop paying additional living expenses until properties are restored.

The insurance industry remains “technically opposed to the bills,” said Karen Collins, a vice president at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association and a member of the smoke claims and remediation task force the state’s insurance department formed after the Los Angeles-area fires. 

Although Collins said the bills create a framework, she said specific regulations and standards that result should “remain grounded in science.”

That’s why adjuster Brian Haden is skeptical about the bills, which he says lack specifics. He thinks both sides — fire survivors and insurance companies — will use “whatever’s approved as a weapon.”

“Will the (insurance department) enforce this?” Haden said, adding that he foresees litigation will still be the way disputes will get resolved.

Jane Lawton Potelle, founder and executive director of  Eaton Fire Residents United, whose data helped inform Harabedian’s bill, acknowledged that the bills won’t necessarily solve all enforcement issues.

She also said that although the bills’ standards won’t take effect in time to help her and her fellow survivors directly, she thinks the fact that standards are coming could still affect lawsuits or possible settlements right now.

“Insurers are relying on people not to know information,” she said. “I want people to know how to protect themselves and stop being afraid. Living in a contaminated home can make you sick. And it can devalue your property.”

Other notable bills

State lawmakers also passed legislation that takes aim at insurer behavior. They involve some of the other problems fire survivors mentioned, including long payment delays and insurers’ practice of throwing multiple adjusters at one claim:

Senate Bill 876 requires an insurer to assign a primary point of contact for a customer within 30 days of a claim being filed and send a written report to that customer whenever it assigns a third adjuster within six months. It also includes rules requiring insurers to disclose more information:  They must submit detailed disaster response plans to the insurance department by April 1, 2028. Those plans would need to be updated every two years or upon the insurance commissioner’s request.

Senate Bill 877 says all preliminary and final calculations related to the amount of loss, covered damage and cost of repairs must be included in claims-related documents insurers provide to their customers within 15 days of a request.

Senate Bill 878 requires insurers to pay the customer the cash value of a property within 30 calendar days of it being deemed a total loss. Subsequently, after receiving proof and documentation, if a policy requires it, insurers must pay the rest of the replacement cost within 30 days. Insurers will owe accrued interest on those amounts if they don’t make payments within 30 days.

This story originally appeared in CalMatters.

You’ve read the story. Help fund the next one.

Reporting doesn’t happen because someone clicks. It happens because someone pays for the time it takes to ask questions, check facts and get the story right.

We make that work free to read. We’re asking you to help make it possible.

If this reporting matters to you, don’t stop at reading. Make a donation today.

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.
Help pay for the reporting
Tagged: asbestos, California Department of Insurance, California FAIR Plan, California Legislature, CalMatters, Department of Toxic Substances Control, Disaster Recovery, Eaton Fire, fire damage, Gavin Newsom, homeowners insurance, insurance, John Harabedian, lead, legislation, Los Angeles County, Mike Gipson, Palisades Fire, Smoke Damage, State Farm, Toxic Contamination, wildfire recovery, wildfires
Local News Matters
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS

Bay City News Foundation
(510) 251-8100
[email protected]

Staff Page

Terms of Use

FIND MORE STORIES

  • Local & Community News
  • California News
  • Politics & Civic Engagement
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
  • The Big Issues
  • Arts & Culture
  • Education & Youth Voices
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
  • Special Projects
  • About Bay City News
© 2026 Connecting audiences with quality, local news Powered by Newspack

Nonprofit. Local. Reader-funded.

What would happen if local news went away?

Because of donors like you,
we’re still here.

Democracy needs nonprofit journalism, and Northern California deserves reporting that holds power accountable and keeps communities informed. We won’t back down from that mission. But we can’t do it without you.

What would happen if local news went away?

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.

$
$
$

Your contribution is appreciated.

Sign in or register

Or

Sign in by entering the code we sent to , or clicking the magic link in the email.

Forgot password
Continue Set a password (optional)

Terms & Conditions. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Register

We'll create a new account for .

Sign up for newsletters

Get the best of Local News Matters directly in your email inbox.

Sending to:

Gift this article

Loading Comments...

Complete your transaction