The Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors held a community forum Tuesday to discuss the role county law enforcement played in assisting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in 2025.
Over more than two hours, the supervisors received presentations from Sheriff David Livingston and an immigrant rights organization and heard from community members who, for the most part, called on the sheriff to end all cooperation with ICE.
The meeting was required under California’s Transparent Review of Unjust Transfers and Holds Act, or the TRUTH Act. Enacted in 2018, the law requires an annual forum to publicly disclose and explain any qualifying cooperation between local law enforcement and ICE during the previous year.
The law is considered a companion to Senate Bill 54, also known as the California Values Act, which limits state and local resources from being used to carry out immigration detentions and deportations.
In his presentation, Livingston emphasized that his department does not participate directly in immigration enforcement but, pursuant to SB 54, notifies ICE of the release dates of certain immigrants held in county jails with serious felony or misdemeanor convictions.
In 2025, Livingston said, ICE made 724 notification requests to his office, of which only 124 qualifying requests were completed. Of those, 32 were repeat notifications involving the same individuals, who were detained and released multiple times during the year.
As a result, the Sheriff’s Office notified ICE of the release dates of 92 unique individuals.
Their crimes included assault, burglary, possession of firearms, sexual assault, DUI and elder abuse, among others. All but one of the individuals had prior conviction histories, according to data in Livingston’s presentation.
“What you need to remember,” Livingston said, “is that many of the victims of these crimes are themselves immigrants. So, it’s a Catch-22 for our deputies.”
Livingston reiterated that notifying ICE of release dates was the only involvement his office had in immigration enforcement.
“We don’t assist ICE, we don’t track ICE,” he said. “They can only go where the public can go,” clarifying that his officers do not help immigration officers if they come to pick up a detained individual after their release.
Does this county really want to align with a regime that is killing people?
Miosotti Tenecora, Immigrant Legal Resource Center senior staff attorney
But in her own presentation, Miosotti Tenecora, a senior staff attorney at the immigrant rights group Immigrant Legal Resource Center, questioned whether all 92 individuals qualified under SB 54 for notification to ICE in the first place.
For instance, Tenecora said a couple of individuals with misdemeanor convictions were referred to ICE, but in her reading of the law, their crimes were not serious enough to warrant referral under SB 54.
“Immigration law is one of the most complex areas of law, I should know,” Tenecora said. “And that analysis cannot be made by someone without an immigration law background.”
She called on the Sheriff’s Office to cease all cooperation with ICE.
“Does this county really want to align with a regime that is killing people?” she asked.
During the public comment period that followed the presentations, community members mostly echoed Tenecora’s sentiment.
‘An obligation to the community’
District 5 Supervisor Shanelle Scales-Preston asked Livingston why his office continued notifying ICE when not doing so is an option. She cited San Mateo County as an example, where the Sheriff’s Office did not complete a single notification request from ICE in 2025.
“We have an obligation to the community at large to provide public safety services,” Livingston said in response. “If they [immigrants] are here, they commit crime after crime after crime, and ICE wants to interview them or detain them, we allow that,” he added.
The conversation over the county’s cooperation with ICE will continue Sept. 8, when the Board of Supervisors will discuss a proposed non-cooperation policy, a revision to an ordinance that the board delayed voting on in July.
