Plans for a large, market-rate apartment complex in Vacaville will move forward despite some pushback from residents and housing advocates who question the city’s prioritization of above-market instead of affordable housing.

The 82-unit Sapphire Luxury Apartments is planned for a long-vacant lot at 561 Peabody Road, next to the Dollar Tree. The project applicant is JG Estates, a Fairfield-based developer, according to planning documents.

In a neighborhood meeting about the project held earlier this year and on social media, residents have noted the lack of accessible housing in the proposal.

On Tuesday, commissioners echoed community concerns before ultimately voting to allow the project to bypass further environmental review, allowing it to go forward.

Planning Commissioner Ashley Banta agreed that developments have not been geared toward affordability.

“We’re not building things that people can afford,” said Banta, responding to the planning department’s presentation.

Banta noted that high home prices impact everyday Vacaville residents.

“It’s not just low-income; it’s not someone that’s homeless on the street. It’s your person that’s making decent wages that cannot afford to live here,” she said.

The market-rate development is a go, despite requirements in Vacaville’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation, a state mandate that the city should work to build nearly 2,000 apartments for extremely low- to moderate-income households, according to the most recent progress report.

The report notes that only 6 affordable units have been built in Vacaville since 2022. The city has a long way to go: The RHNA calls for the city to build another 404 moderate-income units, 403 low-income units, 677 very low-income units and 339 extremely low-income units. Conversely, the city has exceeded its allotted 1,105 above moderate-income units.

Planning Commissioner Doug Beaumont said he was at least happy that something would be going into the empty lot.

“I like the project,” said Beaumont in an interview. “It’s a good location. It’s using land that wasn’t being used,” he said.

Per the RHNA, cities aren’t exactly required to fulfill state mandated affordable housing obligations; They only need to show they’re working toward it, said Beaumont.

Cities must have plans in the works for affordable housing and need to zone for them, according to state law, but mandates to actually build them are not in the law.

But without additional funds from the state to actually build homes for low-income residents, he said, it’s up to private developers to meet those housing needs.

“Unless you get funding from the state to supplement it, the builders aren’t going to build it,” said Beaumont. “It’s just pie in the sky.”

‘A no-win situation’

To confront the issue, a number of Bay Area cities have what are called inclusionary housing ordinances. In San Francisco, a project with more than 25 units is required to include a percentage of affordable apartments into the existing plans. Developers also have the option to propose the units for a separate site or just dodge all the building and pay a fee to the city.

Nearby Vallejo is in the process of passing its own ordinance, which would require developments with more than 20 units to add a fixed portion of affordable units, according to the city’s draft proposal of the rule.

But Vacaville has no such ordinance. Typically, said city Senior Planner Albert Enault, developers simply opt not to consider affordability, though Planning Department staff tries to have those conversations.

“It’s kind of a no-win situation,” said Beaumont. “The city doesn’t win, really. The people looking for affordable housing can’t win. You’re kind of stuck.”

In Vacaville, very low- to low-income for a household of four ranges from below $49,650 to $79,440; above moderate income starts at $119,160, according to the city’s housing element site.

Vacaville is more affordable than many parts of the Bay Area. But the small city of 103,181 people is steadily growing every year, and housing affordability is a top concern for residents, according to a survey presented to the City Council in June.

The area median rent for a market-rate 1-bedroom in Vacaville is about $2,070 a month, with 2-bedrooms at $2,323 a month and 3-bedrooms at $3,137 a month, according to a recent city rent survey.

At the meeting, Enault said that many recent projects that staff hoped would have affordable units do not — including hundreds of units in the recently approved developments such as Independence in Vacaville and the Orange Apartments and Retail development.

“You’re allowing residential development to move forward, but there’s no requirement to build affordable units, how are we getting them built?” said Enault.

City planners said on Tuesday they pitched an “alternative housing site” to JG Estates as a way to include affordable housing in the plans — 46 lower-income units on Vineyard Valley Way and Markham Avenue about a mile and a half north of Sapphire Luxury Apartments.

Enault said they’re still in talks with JG Estates to bring in affordable units. With past developments, he said, talk was about as far as it got.

“Then, the buck usually stops there,” he said.