A group of California state legislators, Head Start California representatives and supporters of early childhood education gathered Wednesday to voice opposition to a proposed federal rule change that would significantly weaken standards for the early childhood education program Head Start.
First established by Congress in the 1960s, Head Start is a federally funded program that provides child care, early education, health and dental checkups and support to vulnerable and low-income communities, including children with disabilities, children experiencing homelessness and children in foster care.
Head Start had a showing of bipartisan support at the event, from Assemblymember Patrick Ahrens, D-Silicon Valley, and Assemblymember Heather Hadwick, R-Redding, both of whom participated in the program as children.
“We’re here to simply come together in a bipartisan fashion to say how important Head Start is. This is personal for us,” said Ahrens at the event. “This is one of the few programs that the government helps to support where we see a direct economic benefit to communities … it is a lifeline for families and children, and we need to help our most vulnerable.”
Hadwick added that Head Start remains one of the few programs that serves kids in rural and remote communities, potentially serving as the only source of child care for some families. She said that Head Start provides an economic benefit to these small communities by allowing parents to work while their children receive developmental education that supports better long-term outcomes.
Advocates warn of weakened standards
The key provisions of concern raised at the event centered on changes that would establish English-only instruction mandates, eliminate class-size and teacher-to-child ratio requirements, reduce disability service protections and create new enrollment documentation barriers, among other things.
On Friday, the Trump administration released a proposed rule change that would revise the performance standards of Head Start with a goal of “reducing the federal burden” of the program, deferring responsibility to states or local policies whenever possible.
According to the rule, the proposed changes will “eliminate restrictive Federal regulations, [and] empower small and local businesses, freeing them to focus on excellence in service delivery rather than bureaucratic compliance.”
Luis Bautista, executive director of the Los Angeles County Office of Education Head Start program, said the rules that Head Start currently abides by are supported by years of research and create a standardized program for students around the country.
This is personal for us. This is one of the few programs that the government helps to support where we see a direct economic benefit to communities.
Assemblymember Patrick Ahrens, D-Silicon Valley
“One of the things that makes Head Start unique is that there’s no other equivalent to it in [California], and really across the country, and partly it’s because it is a whole-child, whole-family approach to supporting children in their school readiness,” said Bautista at the event. “Head Start has delivered measurable returns for more than 60 years because it combines high-quality early learning with comprehensive family supports.”
Miriam McNamara, program director of the North Coast Opportunities Head Start program, added that Head Start is considered the “gold standard” of early childhood care that states around the country model policy after. If standards change and institutional knowledge slowly goes away as people retire, those standards will naturally loosen, diminishing results, she said.
The administration’s proposal needs to go through a 60-day public comment period, at which point comments will be responded to and the language of the rule will be finalized.
Melanee Cottrill, executive director of Head Start California, encouraged supporters to voice their opposition to the rule change.
