Raised: 41300
Goal: 200000
Nonprofit. Local. Reader-funded.
Because of donors like you,
we’re still here.
Democracy needs nonprofit journalism, and Northern California deserves reporting that holds power accountable and keeps communities informed. We won’t back down from that mission. But we can’t do it without you.
What would happen if local news went away?
Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.
We'll create a new account for .
Get the best of Local News Matters directly in your email inbox.
Sending to:
Fremont council shelves charter city proposal after poll shows weak public support
Share this:
At a packed meeting Tuesday, the Fremont City Council voted unanimously against adding a city charter to the November ballot.
Fremont voters will need to wait until possibly the next municipal election in 2028 to decide whether their city should remain a general law city beholden to state laws or transition to a charter city with its own local constitution.
Prior to Tuesday’s meeting, a third-party polling firm last month surveyed 611 Fremont residents to assess, among other items, whether they supported the final city charter drafted by a mayor-appointed committee.
Only 25% of survey respondents said “yes,” and nearly 60% said “no.” The remaining were undecided.
Fremont is the only general law city among the five largest cities by population in the Bay Area.
The charter city plan was proposed in February by Vice Mayor Yajing Zhang. The main goal was to improve the efficiency of Fremont’s local government.
Presenting the proposal
Mayor Raj Salwan appointed a seven-member Charter Advisory Committee in March. The committee was tasked with drafting a city charter that would define the structure and authorities of the City Council.
The committee held six public hearings in March and April. The initial charter draft was presented to the City Council on June 2.
The charter blueprint authorized the following: the continuance of the relationship between the City Council and the city manager, where the former creates policy and the latter is responsible for the day-to-day implementation of policy; maintenance of the part-time status of the City Council members; City Council confirmation of all city department heads appointed by the city manager; an increase of term limits for the mayor and council members from two to three consecutive four-year terms; an increase in health benefits to council members commensurate with that of city employees; and an allocation of 1.5 employees to support the City Council.
After the June 2 public hearing, the council approved the committee’s recommendations and instructed members to add the following to its second draft: the ability of the mayor to independently add items to the City Council meeting agendas; the ability of the city attorney to hire and fire their staff; clarification that the City Council may participate in the hiring and firing of direct staff; and development of a process to fill any future vacant City Council seats.
Resident and former City Councilmember Dominic Dutra speaks during public comments at the Fremont City Council special meeting to consider a charter city proposal on Tuesday, July 28, 2026. “You don’t listen to us,” he told the councilmembers while speaking against the proposal. “We asked you to please come listen to us.” (Framegrab from video via City of Fremont)
Most of the provisions could be enacted without a city charter, according to City Attorney Rafael Alvarado.
The maximum one-time cost to place the charter on the November ballot was more than $850,000, to be drawn from the city’s general fund. The cost of placing a measure on the ballot is calculated by multiplying the number of registered voters by the cost per voter determined by the county’s Registrar of Voters. The county registrar estimated that the cost per voter for placing a measure on the November ballot was $5 to $7.
Public speakers debate pros and cons
About 40 people spoke during the public comment period at Tuesday’s meeting.
Supporters of the city charter cited the need for more local governance of a growing, diverse city. Fremont has more than 230,000 residents, with nearly half born outside the United States, and more than 60% speak a language other than English at home, according to the city’s website.
Detractors of the city charter cited the rushed timeframe that resulted in a watered-down charter that lacked broad community support and was not worth the $800,000-plus price tag. Critics also said that the City Council did not provide a robust enough argument as to why Fremont needed to become a charter city.
Salwan laid out an optimistic overview of the entire charter city proposal leading up to Tuesday’s final vote.
“More Fremont residents understand what a charter is today than at many previous points in our history. That alone is an achievement,” said Salwan. “A city should look hard at its own governance every few years … because the community’s needs change over the years, and the public’s expectations of us are higher than any time in our history. The residents don’t grade us on our structure. They grade us on whether we deliver. And nothing, nothing matters more to me and to this Council than our ability to get things done.”
In addition to deferring a city charter to a possible future election, the City Council also voted to continue community dialogue on the matter. Future meetings will be planned to decide which of the charter items could be passed under the ordinances of a general law city.
Josephine Tsai, Bay City News
A graduate student at the Craig Newmark School of Journalism in New York City and a retired physician, Josephine brings a unique perspective to health and science reporting. She's also eager to expand her skills in audio journalism and long-form storytelling.
More by Josephine Tsai, Bay City News