The city of San Rafael will be asking voters to approve a sharp increase in the city’s real property transfer tax, from 0.2% to 1%, to raise money for police, fire, roads and parks.
The City Council voted Monday to add the measure to the Nov. 3 ballot.
A property transfer tax is a one-time tax charged when ownership of real property is transferred from one party to another, usually at the time of sale. It differs from property tax, which is assessed annually.
The measure will increase the real property transfer rate from $2 to $10 per $1,000 of the transaction value. If passed, it will generate an estimated $6 million per year to help cover General Fund deficits through 2029. The measure will require a simple majority to pass.
“The real question is whether it is borne by the buyer or the seller of the property,” said Paul Navazio, San Rafael interim city manager, to the council.
“I can promise you that the sellers will bear these transfer tax costs 99% of the time,” said public commenter Phoebe Reyes. “I have a client who’s selling right now, and the only reason he’s selling in San Rafael is because he’s got to pay $8,000 for his wife’s memory care plus the thousands of dollars he needs to go into assisted living.”
Resident Jenn Pfeiffer also voiced her opposition to the measure.
“I have a listing now closing this Friday for $3.3 million,” she said. “The trustees are paying $6,000 in city transfer taxes. If this were to pass, they would pay $30,000. Do you want to come to my listing appointments with me and try to explain this?”
Funding roads and public safety
Navazio said without the money, the city will continue to see a decline in roadway, sidewalk and storm drain conditions as well as other maintenance needs. “We are $2.5 million to $3 million short of being able to fund our ongoing street pavement maintenance program at a level required to actually maintain current conditions, let alone improve them,” said Navazio.
Navazio said the city has identified about $10 million in funding needs over the next 10 years, adding that approximately $4 million of the new revenue would be allocated for infrastructure improvements. Another $2 million would go toward public safety to buy two new ambulance/paramedic units and permanently fund the SAFE Team, an alternative service that responds to calls related to people experiencing homelessness or individuals in crisis.
According to Navazio, San Rafael retains only 12.2% of the property tax revenue paid by property owners. Marin County gets 19.2% of the property tax revenue.
“This is one of the reasons San Rafael continues to rely on additional funding sources, such as voter-approved sales tax measures, library tax measures and paramedic tax measures, to bridge the gap between services and revenues,” Navazio said.
But for resident Chris Backer, quadrupling the tax rate would hurt his older real estate clients.
“Just going at a small group of people doesn’t seem like a very intelligent way to try to fund the services,” he said at the meeting. “It starts to add up, and that’s why people aren’t moving. Those are the population we need to get out of their homes.”
