A ballot measure to introduce rent control in Redwood City will be decided by voters in the November election after the City Council formally placed the measure on the ballot at Tuesday’s meeting.
The council was tasked with either approving the ordinance or deciding to give voters a say. But during the nearly four-hour presentation and discussion, most councilmembers took issue with many of the proposal’s provisions.
“I have grave concerns about the implications of this ordinance and the regulations to implement this ordinance,” said Vice Mayor Kaia Eakin. “I hope that the voters avail themselves of information when they vote, but I will support putting it on the ballot.”
The measure, called the “Redwood City Fair and Affordable Housing Ordinance,” started as a grassroots initiative that gathered enough signatures to qualify for the November ballot.
Economic and Planning Systems, a real estate economics firm, conducted a supplemental report evaluating the fiscal and economic implications of the proposed measure. The report concluded that the city would incur “significant one-time and ongoing costs” to implement the rent control program.
It also found that the ordinance could discourage housing growth, place significant burdens on landlords and cause financial strain on deed-restricted affordable housing.
“This legislation is not the answer,” said Councilmember Diane Howard. “I think the unintended consequences will be momentous.”
The 46-page ordinance limits rent increases and expands tenant protections beyond state law.
It proposes an annual rent increase cap of 60% of the percentage change in the Consumer Price Index, or CPI. Rent stabilization would apply to rental units built before 1995, in accordance with the state Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act, which limits the scope of local rent control.
Costa-Hawkins exempts single-family homes and condominiums from rent control. But if the law were repealed in the future, those homes would become subject to the ordinance.
The measure also introduces stronger tenant protections related to just cause for eviction, the right to return, relocation assistance and anti-harassment. It adds protections for students, educators, older adults, tenants with disabilities and terminally ill tenants.
Supporters, opponents weigh in
While the proposed rent caps are limited to certain types of units, the tenant protection provisions would apply to all rental units in Redwood City.
Councilmembers emphasized that the city did not draft the ordinance. The Affordable Redwood City ballot committee gathered more than 7,500 signatures to qualify the measure for the ballot.
“This initiative was not drafted by the city,” said Councilmember Jeff Gee. “It was drafted by other people that have not stood up here and said they wrote it.”
Clara Jaeckel, a Redwood City renter, spoke in support of the initiative.
“Everyone deserves a safe and dignified place to live,” she said. “The main benefit and impact of the Fair and Affordable Housing Ordinance is making it possible for Redwood City families, your constituents who are facing severe rent burden, to stay in their homes.”

Several landlords and real estate agents spoke during public comment, saying the provisions would impose greater costs on them and the city.
“The measure affects city resources, housing preservation and the city’s long-term economic health,” said Rhovy Antonio, senior vice president of public affairs for the California Apartment Association, which represents rental property owners in Redwood City.
“This 46-page initiative brings legal, financial and economic liability for all Redwood City residents,” she said. “All of the warning signs in the report are too significant to ignore.”
Who pays the cost?
To cover ongoing costs associated with the program, estimated at between $5 million and $11 million, property owners of rent-controlled units would be charged fees. The ordinance also requires the city to cover legal fees associated with litigation brought by tenants against landlords.
The ordinance states that funding for the program cannot come from the city’s general fund.
“When I think of our fiduciary responsibilities, I don’t see the cost recovery,” said Councilmember Marcella Padilla. “I don’t see how this doesn’t hit the general fund. I don’t see how this doesn’t hurt all taxpayers. I just don’t see how this can be funded the way it is written.”
Landlords would also have to pay tenants’ utilities unless buildings have separately metered utilities, which many pre-1995 buildings do not. The ordinance also requires landlords to provide a tenant safety plan when undertaking repairs or construction, and those plans would need city approval.
The report said the ordinance could create financial strain on deed-restricted affordable housing, particularly the more than 600 units in Redwood City built before 1995, which would be subject to rent control program fees.
“Policies like this might limit the truly affordable units,” Howard said. “Will we be able to produce new affordable units in Redwood City? Not likely, not with this.”
The council unanimously voted to send the ordinance to voters.
“We are compelled by law to send it to the voters,” said Councilmember Isabella Chu. “That’s what we need to do, but I would like to formally oppose this ordinance because I believe it will really hurt the people it is most intended to help.”

