THOUSANDS OF RESIDENTS in Alameda and Contra Costa counties wondered what was going on when they smelled smoke on Sept. 8. Within a few hours, local officials shared the source: a prescribed fire on Angel Island.

Cal Fire, the Bay Area Air District, and the Marin County Fire Department thought the smoke would blow across the ocean, but the winds changed that Tuesday afternoon and the smoke went inland. In a Facebook post, Contra Costa County District 1 Supervisor John Gioia, who serves on the Bay Area Air District board, wrote, โWhen the burn was planned … the weather forecast called for winds which would have directed the smoke out over the Golden Gate but at the last minute winds shifted causing the smoke to instead impact West Contra Costa County.โ
The incident raised questions and awareness around the decision-making and communication for prescribed burns.
Prescribed burns are scheduled, methodical burns meant to โuse fire as a tool,โ according to Scott Stephens, professor of fire science and forest policy at UC Berkeley. Stephens says there are a number of functions of prescribed burns, including trying to lower the risk of wildfires, clearing excess vegetation, or helping restore plants and the ecosystem.
Prescribed burns are overwhelmingly organized and controlled, with โ99.8%โ of them staying within their intended lines, according to Len Neil, Cal Fire chief of staff for Prescribed Fire and Environmental Protection.
Complicated by climate change
Cal Fire oversees more than 800 burns yearly, Neil said. Prescribed burns are supposed to burn dried vegetation and dense brush, reducing potential wildfire fuel. Very few of them are newsworthy since they do what theyโre supposed to do, Neil said. Even those that do get out of line rarely cause any trouble. โWeโre trying to have a campaign of โfight fire with fire,โ so the public is aware that we use fire as a tool.โย
Cal Fire has been conducting burns since the early 1970s. The number of controlled burns has increased in recent years because of more awareness of wildfire risk and a larger workforce to manage prescribed burns, according to Stephens.ย
Stephens describes how historically there was a predictable week to 10 days that were considered good conditions for prescribed burning during the spring or fall. Climate change makes these less predictable. During the summer, the land is often too dry with uncertain conditions, making it unsafe to do controlled burns. While climate change has made fewer days to burn in the spring and fall, it has opened up winter as an option.
Stephens explained that to ensure prescribed burns are safe, those responsible for the burns โ firefighters or others contracted for this work โ follow a series of safety steps.

Safety before the flames
The first step is to create a burn plan. This specifies the objective or goals of the prescribed fire, as well as the conditions necessary for the burn to take place. This plan includes considering weather conditions and how to prevent the spread of the fire outside the chosen area. The burn plan also includes contingencies that outline what the burners will do if the fire goes beyond the specified area or who to call in an emergency. After this, the burn plan is reviewed by the local fire department.ย
In Contra Costa County, it is the Contra Costa County Fire Protection District. Once the burn plan is approved, there is a smoke management plan. This includes modeling where the smoke from the fire will go to make sure thereโs not too much smoke or smoke in unsafe areas, such as roads.ย
Cal Fire has increased its number of controlled burns in recent years because of more awareness of wildfire risk and a larger workforce to manage prescribed burns.
After the burn plan and smoke plan are approved, a crew is formed to do the burn. This can be state park employees or experts in controlled burning. The fire is supervised by the incident command system that follows strict protocols in the management, strategy and tactics of the incident. The incident commander is responsible for the management of the incident.
Long before Cal Fire
Stephens points out that prescribed burns are a part of California history. He explains that for Indigenous people, burning was โtheir number one toolโ for managing landscapes used for food and medicine.
Stephens said prescribed burns are less common these days in California. He compares the 2 million acres burned yearly in Florida to the 100,000 acres burned yearly in California.ย
So what should you do if you smell smoke or notice a fire? One resource is the Watch Duty app. Watch Duty has a map showing many different fires around the U.S., with green fire icons representing prescribed burns. This app usually has current information on fires, including the type and location of the fire. In the case of the Angel Island fire, it showed that it was a prescribed burn, helping those who might be worried about a wildfire.
Another resource, according to Neil, is the Prescribed Fire Information Reporting System (PFIRS), which shows prescribed fires in California.
Rachel Rossย is a senior at El Cerrito High School in El Cerrito and a CCYJ reporter.ย This story originally appeared in CCSpin.
