Raised: 41300

Goal: 200000

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.

Help us raise for local news

raised Goal

Learn more Give now
  • DONATE TO SUPPORT LOCAL NEWS!
  • Sign In
  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS

  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
Skip to content
Local News Matters

Local News Matters

Connecting audiences with quality, local news

  • DONATE TO SUPPORT LOCAL NEWS!
  • Sign In
Sign In
  • Local News
    • Featured News
    • Bay Area News
    • Marin News Matters
    • Santa Clara County News Matters
    • Mendocino News Matters
    • Stockton News Matters
    • Equity Ripples
    • Amplifying Voices
    • Inspire Me
  • CA News
    • California Currents
    • California Local
    • KQED
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
    • Inside/Out
    • Crime & Public Safety
    • Prison News
  • The Big Issues
    • Living Longer & Aging in the Bay Area
    • Housing & Homelessness
    • Public Health
    • Environment
  • Arts & Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Bay City Books
    • Travel
    • Bay City Sketchbook
  • Education & Youth Voices
    • Education Matters
    • Youth Voices
    • Contra Costa Youth Journalism
    • Mosaic
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
    • Experiments with AI
    • Science, Nature & Technology
    • Data Points
  • Special Projects
    • Musk v. Altman
    • Audio Files
    • Bay City Beat
    • Listen In Marin
    • Remember When
    • Talkers
    • Trailblazers
  • Bay City News Labs
    • About Bay City News Labs
  • About Us
    • About Our Staff
    • About Our Board
    • Bay City News Internships
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Newsletters
    • Bay City News … in the News
    • Sponsorships and Advertising
    • Write for Local News Matters
    • Our Policies at a Glance
    • Why We’re Asking for Your Email (And Why It Matters)
  • Election 2026
Posted inLocal News

Grand jury questions VTA’s fiscal oversight of massive $13B Silicon Valley BART extension

by Maryanne Casas-Perez, San Jose Spotlight August 19, 2026August 19, 2026

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
VTA workers install a sound barrier at the Newhall Maintenance Facility in Santa Clara, where early construction work has begun on the BART expansion through Silicon Valley. (VTA via San Jose Spotlight)

VTA OFFICIALS WILL PROVIDE MORE CLARITY about the finances and long-term costs of the massive Silicon Valley BART extension in response to a Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury report that criticized the agency’s management and oversight of the project.

The June 17 report raised concerns about VTA’s financial planning and oversight of the roughly $13 billion effort to bring a six-mile BART extension to Santa Clara and San Jose — including its lack of a dedicated cash-flow model, reliance on uncertain funding sources and failure to consistently account for long-term operations and maintenance costs. It recommended VTA develop a cash-flow model, create an alternative funding strategy and require staff to analyze future operations and maintenance costs before signing off on major design and construction decisions.

“The (VTA board of directors) has recognized the need for additional oversight and guidance, but the board has failed to exercise its obligation to provide the strategic direction needed for a successful project,” the report reads.

On Aug. 13, the BART Silicon Valley Phase II Oversight Committee — a subcommittee of VTA board members — unanimously recommended the full VTA board of directors adopt a revised response to the recommendations. A VTA spokesperson told San José Spotlight the agency will incorporate the oversight committee’s comments before presenting the response to the board on Sept. 3. The public transit agency must submit its final response by Sept. 15.

Board members discussed the project’s costs at the recent meeting. Since 2019, VTA’s general engineering contracts have totaled roughly $544 million, with the oversight committee recently approving a $150 million extension for additional design work. VTA has also been working to patch a nearly $1 billion funding gap in the project.

VTA: Information could be clearer

VTA officials said the transit agency maintains several financial models and daily cash-flow reports, but acknowledged the information could be presented more clearly to decision makers. Deputy General Manager Greg Richardson said VTA needs to better consolidate information so officials have a clearer picture of the project’s finances.

“The model exists, but what we’re attempting to do in 2027 is provide that cash-flow report to this body, to the board, so that it’s … a more succinct, summarized version,” Richardson said.

The discussion comes as the BART extension has undergone significant changes in its design, construction strategy and cost estimates. VTA selected a single-tunnel design for the underground portion of the six-mile extension as it sought to reduce costs and close a funding gap. The project will connect Berryessa/North San Jose to downtown San Jose and Santa Clara with four new stations. The committee also backed a change involving operations and maintenance costs.

The civil grand jury also recommended that VTA require staff to present an operations and maintenance cost analysis when considering major design and construction alternatives. The revised response commits VTA to implementing the recommendation by Dec. 31, 2026.

Suds Jain, a VTA board member and Santa Clara councilmember, said those costs need to be considered when making design decisions because choices made during construction can create expensive maintenance obligations later.

“So that’s why there’s decisions that have to be made looking at how much it’s going to cost to maintain those systems,” Jain said at the meeting. “We have these elevators at the Milpitas station that have glass panels that are custom glass panels, and they break, and they’re unbelievably expensive to maintain. So why do we pick those panels?”

Several factors considered

VTA officials said the agency considers cost, schedule, risk and operations and maintenance impacts when evaluating major design changes. Staff also work with BART, which will operate and maintain the extension, to evaluate how design decisions could affect long-term costs.

The committee also discussed the role of Auditor General Scott Johnson, who provides independent oversight of the project, and whether the committee’s charter and bylaws should be reviewed by the VTA board. Officials agreed to continue evaluating the charter and bylaws rather than create a temporary subcommittee to study the issue. They also agreed to include Johnson’s written response as supplemental information alongside VTA’s official response to the civil grand jury report.

San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan, who sits on the VTA board and oversight committee, said the report provides an opportunity to improve the transit agency’s governance, but disagreed with its broader characterization of the committee.

“I think this is an exceptionally complex and fast moving project,” Mahan said at the meeting. “We do have to ensure the governance model is very clear, providing a charter, showing communication and continuous improvement.”

Monica Mallon, a transit advocate and San José Spotlight columnist, has independently advocated for the BART extension since 2017. She said the civil grand jury’s report raises legitimate concerns about transparency, but should not derail the project.

“I do think that VTA and BART should improve transparency, and should clarify things as much as possible,” Mallon told San José Spotlight. “I don’t think that anything in the report is reason to dramatically change course or stop the project, or stop pursuing state and federal funding for the project in any way.”

 Contact Maryanne Casas-Perez at [email protected] or @CasasPerezRed on X.

This story originally appeared in San Jose Spotlight.

You’ve read the story. Help fund the next one.

Reporting doesn’t happen because someone clicks. It happens because someone pays for the time it takes to ask questions, check facts and get the story right.

We make that work free to read. We’re asking you to help make it possible.

If this reporting matters to you, don’t stop at reading. Make a donation today.

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.
Help pay for the reporting
Tagged: BART, BART Silicon Valley Phase II, civil grand jury, Mayor Matt Mahan, public transit, San Jose, San Jose Spotlight, Santa Clara, Santa Clara County, Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, Silicon Valley BART extension, transportation, VTA
Local News Matters
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS

Bay City News Foundation
(510) 251-8100
[email protected]

Staff Page

Terms of Use

FIND MORE STORIES

  • Local & Community News
  • California News
  • Politics & Civic Engagement
  • Crime, Justice, & Prison News
  • The Big Issues
  • Arts & Culture
  • Education & Youth Voices
  • Technology, AI & Innovation
  • Special Projects
  • About Bay City News
© 2026 Connecting audiences with quality, local news Powered by Newspack

Nonprofit. Local. Reader-funded.

What would happen if local news went away?

Because of donors like you,
we’re still here.

Democracy needs nonprofit journalism, and Northern California deserves reporting that holds power accountable and keeps communities informed. We won’t back down from that mission. But we can’t do it without you.

What would happen if local news went away?

Your gift is tripled
through Dec. 31.

$
$
$

Your contribution is appreciated.

Sign in or register

Or

Sign in by entering the code we sent to , or clicking the magic link in the email.

Forgot password
Continue Set a password (optional)

Terms & Conditions. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Register

We'll create a new account for .

Sign up for newsletters

Get the best of Local News Matters directly in your email inbox.

Sending to:

Gift this article

Loading Comments...

Complete your transaction