Fremont residents packed City Hall on Tuesday for the second and final public hearing to discuss whether the city should remain a general law city beholden to state laws or transition to a charter city with its own local constitution.
“At its heart, this initiative is asking one question,” said Mayor Raj Salwan. “Who should write the rules of how Fremont governs — Fremont or Sacramento?”
In February, the City Council approved a referral from Vice Mayor Yajing Zhang to change Fremont to a charter city with an intention to submit the final charter to a municipal vote on the Nov. 3 ballot. Transitioning to a charter city requires a structured process that includes drafting a city charter, public review and ultimately voter approval.
The mayor appointed a seven-member Charter Advisory Committee tasked with creating a city constitution that would address the structure and authorities of the City Council. The committee held six public meetings in March and April and submitted its first draft to Fremont residents at the first public meeting on June 2. A second charter draft on Tuesday included public comments from the first hearing.
The charter blueprint authorized the following: the continuance of the relationship between the City Council and the city manager, where the former creates policy and the latter is responsible for the day-to-day implementation of policy; City Council confirmation of all city department heads appointed by the city manager; an increase of term limits for the mayor and council members from two to three consecutive four-year terms; and an increase in health benefits to council members commensurate with that of city employees.
City Attorney Rafael Alvarado said that most of the provisions could be enacted without a city charter.
Who should write the rules of how Fremont governs — Fremont or Sacramento?
Mayor Raj Salwan
The maximum estimated cost to place the charter on the November ballot was more than $850,000, to be drawn from the city’s general fund.
Zhang emphasized that the motivation for initiating a city charter was to improve transparency and accountability, particularly in the bidding and procurement of contractors and in light of the 2024 fraud conviction of the prior city manager. Salwan said that the current charter did not include a real property transfer tax, which only a charter city can levy.
About 40 Fremont residents walked up to the podium to respond during their allotted 90 seconds.
Many residents questioned how the charter would benefit the community, with some saying that it was a solution searching for a problem. Some felt that the $800,000-plus price tag to place the charter on the November ballot could be put to better use. A large majority felt that the three-month process to create a new city constitution was too rushed.
“What I would like us to do, and suggestions that I have, would be to pump the brakes a little bit,” said Steve Medeiros, a longtime Fremont resident. “We’ve been general law for this long. What is the hurry to get this to the ballot so quickly?”
Some residents were concerned that the rushed timeline resulted in a threadbare charter that lacked broad community involvement.
“A shift of this magnitude demands meticulous due diligence, comprehensive analysis, and extensive community outreach,” said former vice mayor Sue Chan, who advocated for further study of the initiative. “Without broad public engagement, you compromise the transparency and the process that we owe our residents.”
Supporters cite local control
Supporters of the charter cited the growing needs of a diverse city with a population of 240,000.
“Fremont is not a small or ordinary city. We are one of the largest and most diverse cities in the Bay Area with our own unique needs, challenges and opportunities,” said Dharminder Dewan, who served on the Charter Advisory Committee. “Remaining a general law city limits Fremont to a one-size-fits-all structure. Becoming a charter city gives us the ability to make more local decisions while still remaining fully accountable to the residents and voters of Fremont.”
Anand Vipparthy, a Fremont resident originally from India who also commented at the meeting, said that a city of 240,000 is a small village in his home country.
“You need to always plan ahead. We should have done 10 years before or 20 years before,” said Vipparthy, referring to Fremont becoming a charter city. “The city council represents the people. When a city council represents the people, they need to have some power.”
After the public comments, Zhang told the audience, “I hear you.”
Zhang said she believed that transitioning to a charter city was the right direction for Fremont, but she did ask whether the current charter draft was a “good enough product” or whether more time was needed to finalize a city constitution.
The City Council is expected to decide on July 28 whether to submit a city charter to the November ballot. Fremont residents can review the final charter documents before the meeting no later than July 24.
