Local News Matters weekly newsletter
Start your week with a little inspiration. Sign up for our informative, community-based newsletter, delivered on Mondays with news about the Bay Area.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins preliminarily approved a settlement in a federal class action lawsuit against Alameda County over mental health care at Santa Rita Jail in Dublin and at any other Alameda County jail.
Cousins approved the settlement preliminarily at a virtual hearing Wednesday before attorneys for both sides.
“I am inclined to approve the settlement,” Cousins told the attorneys and others present at the hearing.
The judge also agreed to extend the date for the final approval to Jan. 19. The hearing for the final approval was previously set for Dec. 15. The extended time will give attorneys more time to educate the jail’s incarcerated people on the agreement and more time for people to raise objections to the settlement if they choose to.
“This has been an extensive process that will make our jail safer for staff and those in custody while addressing the specific needs of our population.”Sgt. Ray Kelly, Alameda County Sheriff’s Office
The settlement will require sweeping changes at the jail, not only for people with psychiatric disabilities but for incarcerated people in general. Changes will be made over the next two years and the agreement will be in effect for six years, depending on the progress made.
Besides mental health care, changes will be made to out-of-cell time, ADA accommodations at the jail for people with mental health disabilities, use of force, discharge planning and among other things suicide prevention.
Recent suicides at the jail prompted the lawsuit. Nineteen people died by suicide since 2014 and 31 more died at the jail from other causes. Fifty deaths are a lot for a jail with a population the size of Santa Rita, attorneys for the incarcerated people at Santa Rita said.
Attorney Jeff Bornstein, one of the attorneys representing the jail’s inmates, said significant changes need to be made and they are underway.
Already, a lot fewer people are in restrictive housing, he said.
But, he said, “We have a long way to go.”
“We’re cautiously optimistic,” he said.
Beyond minimum standards
The goal is to make things right at the jail rather than simply meeting the minimum requirements for the treatment of the incarcerated people there, Bornstein said.
He said it would be great if people with mental illness didn’t have to go to jail at all.
A big issue addressed in the agreement is how incarcerated people are treated when they are released. In the past, they have been turned out onto the streets.
Under the settlement, former inmates with serious mental health issues will get a “warm handoff” to community-based providers who can help secure needed resources for them when they are released.
Besides the provision of adequate mental health care, the agreement calls for adequate out-of-cell time each day, including increasing out-of-cell time in the first three months of the agreement.
The agreement also calls for measures to prevent suicide and self-harm among incarcerated people, including limiting the use of safety cells — a small room with nothing but a grate in the floor. The county will be building suicide-resistant cells as part of the agreement and limiting the use of and hopefully phasing out safety cells, Bornstein said.
In all, seven major changes are in store for incarcerated people at the jail. Progress at the jail will be monitored by joint neutral experts and attorneys.
“Our agency is in full support and agreement,” Alameda County Sheriff’s Office spokesman Sgt. Ray Kelly said. “This has been an extensive process that will make our jail safer for staff and those in custody while addressing the specific needs of our population.
“The agreement will bring much needed improvements and resources to our criminal justice system in Alameda County,” he said.